Skip to main content

PART 1 - THINGS TO KNOW BEFORE FILING DEFAMATION COMPLAINT

Being aggrieved of the ruthless comments made upon Birbal by Akbar (His Majesty) in front of the entire Darbar, Birbal has decided to file a Defamation Complaint before the Court of Law. (If you feel clueless, read the first paragraph of - PREVIEW OF DEFAMATION COMPLAINTS PROCEDURE ) Also, Birbal is clueless about the legal process, so he approached Me ( Note: this anecdote is fictional, if you have not realized till now). I had to tell him the following information to make him aware about “Defamation Case Procedures in Indian Courts” in exchange of some legal-fee of course: SECTION 499: Defamation is a Criminal offence under Section 499 of Indian Penal Code . This legal provision contains the legal definition of ‘Defamation’, which has to be followed by Courts and the judicial fraternity in order to convict or acquit an Accused person.   Short-Gyan: Did you know that making defamatory comments against a dead individual is also a criminal defamation offence!   PUNISHME...

WHAT TO DO IF POLICE DOES NOT TAKE ACTION ON MY POLICE COMPLAINT?

ONE MUST ALWAYS TRY TO REFRAIN FROM STEPPING INTO THE CONTOURS OF A COURTROOM, FOR THOSE WHO ENTER ARE FOOLS, WHO VALUE THEIR MONEY OVER THEIR TIME.

                                         - A SMART PERSON

There may be several reasons as to why the Investigation Officer (hereinafter “I.O.”) is not in favour of registering an FIR in your case. Apart from the usual reason, which I am not in favor of mentioning on this online portal, the other reason(s) may include:

  • That, the IO feels your complaint is based on false facts.
  • That, the IO feels your complaint has arisen because of a mere ego-clash between you and the accused.
  • That, the IO feels your complaint do not fall within the four-corners of any criminal offence mentioned under Indian Penal Code or any other Penal Act.
  • That, the IO feels your complaint lacks enough witness/evidences to prove such criminal offence against the Accused.
  • That, the IO feels your complaint is trivial and that you have not suffered any actual damage.
  • That, your complaint is a lost case and will never sustain in front of the Magistrate.

The law is very simple and very clear on this point as mentioned under Section 154 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter “CrPC”) that – "if the offence is a cognizable offence, an FIR shall mandatorily be registered by the Police".

Many people may already know that in order to initiate a criminal action against someone, an F.I.R. is mandatory and the very first document of a criminal process, hence, rightly “setting the criminal law in motion”. Still the question arises “What if the Police still does not take any action, then what?”

WHAT IS THE OTHER WAY TO FILE AN F.I.R.?

There are various other ways of building pressure on the Police to file an FIR in the case, but that might take a substantial amount of money out of the Complainant’s pocket. Let me tell you about the most usual and the cheapest way to do that.



REGISTRATION OF F.I.R. BY POLICE ON THE DIRECTIONS OF MAGISTRATE:

    After following this procedure, if your case and your fortune is good enough, the Magistrate will direct the Police to file the F.I.R. and then the Police will have to file an FIR in your case. The procedure to accomplish the Magistrate's favourable order is as follows: 

(a) Note: Before starting this procedure, it is important that you already have sent the Police Complaint to the Superintendent of Police/ Commissioner of Police and he/she too has not taken any action on the same, just like the IO.

(b)Prepare a Complaint u/s. 156(3) CrPC to be filed before a Magistrate:

It gets a little tricky here. Therefore, people usually contact a lawyer to do this job. But, it depends upon your understanding of law. A Complaint u/s. 156(3) should basically contain the following portions:

        • The Cause Title – The Court before whom you are filing this matter; Name of Parties (i.e. Complainant’s name v/s. Accused Name).
        • Subject of Complaint shall include the section by which this Court is empowered to give you the requisite relief that you are asking (i.e. Section 156(3) of CrPC).
        • Body of the Complaint – This should be the content as mentioned in the Police Complaint. However, as this is going before a Magistrate, you might re-check your grammatical errors and the flow of your arguments. It should ideally be only about the incident and the facts that lead up to the happening of the incident and nothing else.
        • Additional Body – This should contain the exact details of the Police Complaint which was sent to the relevant Police Station as well as the SP/CP, and that they have not taken any action on your complaint. You should attach the Police Complaint bearing the “Acknowledgment stamp & Date” of Police and SP/CP as ‘Annexures’. 
        • Prayer – This should contain the exact reason as to what do you want from this Court. In this case, the reason being “Directing the Police to file an FIR” in your case.

For further information, you may take help from the vast ocean of knowledge i.e. Google or from a mediocre undersigned Advocate.

(c)  File the Complaint in the Court-Office of that specific Magistrate:

For filing this Complaint, you may take help of the Clerks working in such Court office or Peons or an Advocate. After filing the complaint, the matter may take a couple of weeks/months’ time to reach the Board for its First hearing.

(d)  Magistrate to examine the Complainant and Witnesses (if any) on the First Hearing:

Be prepared for your examination by the Magistrate himself. In case the Magistrate need to understand any factual detail, be prepared for that too. Accused will not be called for the hearing at this stage.

After reading your Complaint u/s. 156(3) and the Annexures supporting it, if the Magistrate is of the opinion that a cognizable offence appears to have been committed by the Accused. Then, the Magistrate shall direct the relevant Police authorities to file an FIR and further proceed as per the law laid under CrPC.

 

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TO READ NEXT BLOG CLICK HERE:

WHAT TO DO IF A FALSE F.I.R HAS BEEN FILED AGAINST ME?

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR:

Advocate Shreyas Jain, being a legal practitioner based in Mumbai, specializes in Criminal Law and primarily deal with criminal matters placed before Metropolitan Magistrates and Session Courts at Mumbai & Thane. Mr. Jain is a first generation lawyer and believes in working and excelling at the ground level before going big. You may reach him through his e-mail jainshreyas1995@gmail.com

 

NOTE: VIEWS MENTIONED IN THE ARTICLE ABOVE ARE PERSONAL AND HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH ANY PERSON, PLACE, ORGANISATION OR ANY OTHER FALLING UNDER THE DEFINITION OF ‘PERSON’ UNDER INDIAN PENAL CODE, 1860.

Comments

  1. Veryy well explained! Nice work!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Considering that you are already well aware about this procedure, Krupali, thankyou for being so modest!

      Delete
  2. Very informative and explained in such a simple manner. Great work!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Debo! Applauses from batchmates always feel great. I hope you are fit and fine in this bloody Pandemic.

      Delete
  3. Shreyas , Just a humble suggestion. You can also mention few relevant case laws pertaining to the topic that you post. It will bring more authenticity in your submission and at the same time crate database for you as well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for reading the blog post. Your suggestion is very valid, there is no doubt about it.
      However, I consciously have not included the case laws as I wanted to reach the masses and I was of the opinion that the case laws etc. are not much entertained by non-legal public. Also, I was of the opinion that the blog-post should be in as simple language as possible. I could be wrong!

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

PART 2: PRACTICAL INSIGHTS AND STAGES IN A CHEQUE BOUNCE COMPLAINT

 The content of the last Shorticle, due to its length, had to be cut in two halves. The first half titled " PART 1: PRACTICAL INSIGHTS AND STAGES IN A CHEQUE BOUNCE COMPLAINT " dealt with the procedure uptil THE COURT ISSUING NOTICE AGAINST THE ACCUSED PERSON IN ORDER TO MAKE HIM/HER APPEAR BEFORE THE COURT. Now henceforth, the further Stages in a Cheque Bounce Complaint is as follows:     C.    FIRST APPEARANCE OF THE ACCUSED IN COURT This is a very crucial date of hearing for both Accused and Complainant. Let me point out the things that both the parties (Complainant & Accused) must be aware about:   ACCUSED PERSON: POINTS TO BE KEPT IN MIND ON HIS FIRST APPEARANCE DATE POINT 1: Hire a Lawyer and obtain Bail from the Magistrate. This is a Bailable Offence, so you will get Bail easily. POINT 2: Fulfill all the Bail conditions which are imposed on you. Generally, some monetary amount is to be deposited in the Cash Department of the Court. C...

WHAT ARE BAIL CONDITIONS AND HOW TO FULFILL THEM?

This shorticle, being the last-one from the series – “HOW TO INITIATE/DEFEND CRIMINAL ACTION” , focuses on the very last activity that an Accused person has to undergo so as to obtain Bail. QUICK RECAP: 1.    Accused is arrested. 2.    Accused is produced before Magistrate. 3.    Magistrate confirms the same and decides to continue his Police custody. 4.    After some time, Magistrate decides to change the custody from Police custody to Judicial Custody (i.e. in Jail as undertrial prisoner). 5.    Advocate of Accused files a Bail Application before Magistrate. 6.    Magistrate grants Bail to Accused after executing a CERTAIN AMOUNT OF BOND or SURETY , and also imposes certain CONDITIONS . WHAT IS BOND and SURETY & WHAT ARE THESE CONDITIONS: The Judge, while passing a Bail Order directs the Accused person to execute a Bond with or without Sureties for a certain amount of money. To make the above sentence ...

WHAT TO DO IF THE MAGISTRATE HAS PASSED A REMAND ORDER AGAINST YOU KEEPING YOU UNDER POLICE / JUDICIAL REMAND?

I had discussed in the last shorticle (i.e. short article) about a situation wherein the Police had arrested you and thereafter has produced you before the Magistrate within 24 hours, and such Police Investigating Officer (“ IO ”) had filed a Remand Application against you, requesting the Magistrate to remand you for Police custody (i.e. in police station) or Judicial Custody (i.e. in Jail as under-trial prisoner). Now, what will you do if the Magistrate, after going through the Remand Application, passes an Order for keeping you in Police Custody/Judicial Custody?  This shorticle precisely addresses this practical question of criminal law. REMEDIES AVAILABLE TO YOU AT THIS STAGE: The only remedy available to you at this custody stage is “To obtain Bail from the Magistrate”. But, getting a Bail at this stage is fairly difficult for the primary reason that there will be no ‘change in circumstances’ of the case.   BAIL APPLICATION TO BE MADE ONLY WHEN THERE IS A ‘CHANGE I...